Bring Isobel to Ketheric or Kill Marcus or Not in Baldur’s Gate 3

In the Last Light Inn of Baldur's Gate 3, players come across a black-winged Flaming Fist named Marcus who has received the Ketheric's Blessing. This encounter presents players with two choices: they can either inform Isobel about Marcus' kidnapping and bring her to Ketheric, or they can decide to kill Marcus. Let's explore these options in more detail.

Option 1: Bring Isobel to Ketheric

If players choose to inform Isobel about Marcus' kidnapping, they must refuse to take her and instead engage in a fight with Marcus. This decision has its consequences. During the fight, some refugees may be captured by the Tieflings, adding a sense of urgency to the situation. However, players can later embark on subsequent quests to recover these captured refugees. 

Defeating Marcus in combat has its rewards. Players will gain Jaheira as an accomplice, further strengthening their party. This choice also aligns with the moral objective of saving Isobel and ensuring her safety, as well as the potential rescue of the captured refugees.

Option 2: Kill Marcus

Alternatively, players can choose to hand over Isobel to Marcus, resulting in the deaths of everyone except Isobel and Jaheira. This decision leads to a more sinister outcome and opens up a new quest line focusing on resolving the abduction. Players will have to navigate through the consequences of their actions and find a way to rectify the situation.

Evaluating the Choices

It is essential to evaluate the choices players have in this scenario. Siding with Marcus and handing over Isobel is generally considered a bad choice due to Marcus' evil nature. Furthermore, this decision results in the death of Jaheira, a potential companion and valuable asset to the party. 

On the other hand, fighting Marcus may lead to a few deaths and the temporary capture of some refugees. However, players can undertake a side quest to recover most, if not all, of the refugees, minimizing the negative impact of the encounter.

In conclusion, players in Baldur's Gate 3 are faced with the decision of bringing Isobel to Ketheric or killing Marcus. Choosing to inform Isobel and engage in combat with Marcus leads to a series of consequences, including the capture of refugees by Tieflings. However, these refugees can be rescued through subsequent quests, and players gain Jaheira as a valuable ally. On the other hand, siding with Marcus has severe repercussions, resulting in the deaths of most characters except Isobel and Jaheira. It is crucial for players to carefully consider the outcomes and make a choice that aligns with their moral compass and desired outcomes in the game.